DLR-Logo -> http://www.dlr.de
DLR Portal Home | Imprint | Privacy Policy | Contact | Deutsch
Fontsize: [-] Text [+]

Energetic Comparison of Linear Fresnel and Parabolic Trough Collector Systems

Schenk, Heiko and Hirsch, Tobias and Feldhoff, Jan Fabian and Wittmann, Michael (2014) Energetic Comparison of Linear Fresnel and Parabolic Trough Collector Systems. Journal of Solar Energy Engineering. American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME). doi: 10.1115/1.4027766. ISSN 0199-6231.

[img] PDF - Only accessible within DLR


In recent years, linear Fresnel (LF) collector systems have been developed as a technical alternative to parabolic trough (PT) collector systems. While in the past, LF systems focused on low- and medium-temperature applications, today, LF systems are equipped with vacuum receivers and, therefore, can be operated with similar operating parameters as PT systems. Papers about the technical and economical comparison of specific PT and LF systems have already been published (Dersch et al., 2009, "Comparison of Linear Fresnel and Parabolic Trough Collecor Systems—System Analysis to Determine Break-Even Costs of Linear Fresnel Collectors," Proceedings of the 15th International SolarPACES Symposium, Berlin; Giostri et al. 2011, "Comparison of Two Linear Collectors in Solar Thermal Plants: Parabolic Trough vs. Fresnel," ASME 2011 5th International Conference on Energy Sustainability, Washington, DC; and Morin et al., 2012, "Comparison of Linear Fresnel and Parabolic Trough Collector Power Plants," Sol. Energy, 86(1), pp. 1–12). However, the present paper focuses on the systematic differences in optical and thermodynamic performance and the impact on the economic figures. In a first step the optical performance of typical PT and LF solar fields (SFs) has been examined, showing the differences during the course of the day and annually. Furthermore, the thermodynamic performance, depending on the operating temperature, has been compared. In a second step, the annual electricity yield of typical PT and LF plants has been examined. Solar Salt has been chosen as the heat transfer fluid. Both systems utilize the same power block (PB) and storage type. Solar field size, storage capacity, and PB electrical power are variable, while all examined configurations achieve the same annual electricity yield. As expected for molten salt systems, both systems are the most cost-effective with large storage capacities. The lower thermodynamic performance of the LF system requires a larger SF and lower specific SF costs in order to be competitive. Assuming specific PT field costs of 300 e/m2 aperture, the break-even costs of the LF system with Solar Salt range between 202 and 235 e/m2, depending on the site and storage capacity. In order to confirm the major statements, within a sensitivity analysis, it is shown that a variation of SF and storage costs does not have a significant impact on the relative break-even costs of the LF system. [DOI: 10.1115/1.4027766]

Item URL in elib:https://elib.dlr.de/99134/
Document Type:Article
Title:Energetic Comparison of Linear Fresnel and Parabolic Trough Collector Systems
AuthorsInstitution or Email of AuthorsAuthor's ORCID iDORCID Put Code
Hirsch, TobiasUNSPECIFIEDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-0063-0128UNSPECIFIED
Feldhoff, Jan FabianUNSPECIFIEDhttps://orcid.org/0000-0003-1636-5429UNSPECIFIED
Journal or Publication Title:Journal of Solar Energy Engineering
Refereed publication:Yes
Open Access:No
Gold Open Access:No
In ISI Web of Science:Yes
Publisher:American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME)
Keywords:linear Fresnel, parabolic trough, system comparison, solar thermal power plant, thermal energy storage, solar field cost, molten salt
HGF - Research field:Energy
HGF - Program:Renewable Energies
HGF - Program Themes:Concentrating Solar Systems (old)
DLR - Research area:Energy
DLR - Program:E SF - Solar research
DLR - Research theme (Project):E - Line-Focusing Systems (old)
Location: Stuttgart
Institutes and Institutions:Institute of Solar Research
Institute of Solar Research > Linienfokussierende Systeme
Deposited By: Schenk, Heiko
Deposited On:05 Nov 2015 13:07
Last Modified:29 Nov 2023 11:55

Repository Staff Only: item control page

Help & Contact
electronic library is running on EPrints 3.3.12
Website and database design: Copyright © German Aerospace Center (DLR). All rights reserved.