elib
DLR-Header
DLR-Logo -> http://www.dlr.de
DLR Portal Home | Impressum | Datenschutz | Kontakt | English
Schriftgröße: [-] Text [+]

Assessment of policies and detection of unintended effects: Guiding principles for the consideration of methods and tools in policy-packaging

Justen, Andreas und Schippl, Jens und Lenz, Barbara und Fleischer, Torsten (2013) Assessment of policies and detection of unintended effects: Guiding principles for the consideration of methods and tools in policy-packaging. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 60 (02/14), Seiten 19-30. Elsevier. doi: 10.1016/j.tra.2013.10.015. ISSN 0965-8564.

Dieses Archiv kann nicht den Volltext zur Verfügung stellen.

Offizielle URL: http://www.elsevier.com/locate/tra

Kurzfassung

Single policies or entire policy packages are often assessed using different methods aiming at a quantification of effects as well as the detection of undesired outcomes. The knowledge of potential impacts is essential to take informed policy actions. Hence, there is a constant need for efficient assessment approaches to support policy decision-making. A broad range of such assessment methods is used in policymaking. Some of them are using quantitative data; others are characterized by qualitative information, observations or opinions. Practical experiences with transport policy prove that these methods all have their pros and cons, but none of them are able to detect the full range of effects. This leads to important questions this article deals with, such as what are the strengths and limitations of the different tools and methods for assessing impacts, and how should different approaches be integrated into the policymaking processes? We analyze the ability of assessment methods to detect different kinds of intended and unintended effects, and introduce the concepts of structurally open (mainly qualitative) and structurally closed (mainly quantitative) methods. It is argued that these concepts support making the pros and cons of the tools and methods more explicit and, thus, allow integrating the different tools and methods into the process of policy packaging. Based on a policy package example, we provide practical recommendations on how to integrate different assessment methods adequately and show that both quantitative and qualitative tools should be used in different phases of the process. The main recommendation is to alternate the application of assessment methods with structurally open methods used in the beginning and the end of the policymaking process and applying structurally closed methods in between.

elib-URL des Eintrags:https://elib.dlr.de/90311/
Dokumentart:Zeitschriftenbeitrag
Titel:Assessment of policies and detection of unintended effects: Guiding principles for the consideration of methods and tools in policy-packaging
Autoren:
AutorenInstitution oder E-Mail-AdresseAutoren-ORCID-iDORCID Put Code
Justen, AndreasAndreas.Justen (at) dlr.deNICHT SPEZIFIZIERTNICHT SPEZIFIZIERT
Schippl, Jensjens.schippl (at) kit.eduNICHT SPEZIFIZIERTNICHT SPEZIFIZIERT
Lenz, Barbarabarbara.lenz (at) dlr.deNICHT SPEZIFIZIERTNICHT SPEZIFIZIERT
Fleischer, Torstentorsten.fleischer (at) kit.eduNICHT SPEZIFIZIERTNICHT SPEZIFIZIERT
Datum:2013
Erschienen in:Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice
Referierte Publikation:Ja
Open Access:Nein
Gold Open Access:Nein
In SCOPUS:Ja
In ISI Web of Science:Ja
Band:60
DOI:10.1016/j.tra.2013.10.015
Seitenbereich:Seiten 19-30
Herausgeber:
HerausgeberInstitution und/oder E-Mail-Adresse der HerausgeberHerausgeber-ORCID-iDORCID Put Code
de D. Ortúzar, J.Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, ChileNICHT SPEZIFIZIERTNICHT SPEZIFIZIERT
Rose, J.M.University of South Australia, North Sydney, New South Wales, AustraliaNICHT SPEZIFIZIERTNICHT SPEZIFIZIERT
Verlag:Elsevier
Name der Reihe:ScienceDirect
ISSN:0965-8564
Status:veröffentlicht
Stichwörter:Transport policy analysis, Assessment methods, Policy packaging, Unintended policy effects
HGF - Forschungsbereich:Luftfahrt, Raumfahrt und Verkehr
HGF - Programm:Verkehr
HGF - Programmthema:Verkehrssystem
DLR - Schwerpunkt:Verkehr
DLR - Forschungsgebiet:V VS - Verkehrssystem
DLR - Teilgebiet (Projekt, Vorhaben):V - Verkehrsentwicklung und Umwelt II (alt)
Standort: Berlin-Adlershof
Institute & Einrichtungen:Institut für Verkehrsforschung
Hinterlegt von: Zeppan, Katja
Hinterlegt am:25 Aug 2014 15:05
Letzte Änderung:07 Nov 2023 08:38

Nur für Mitarbeiter des Archivs: Kontrollseite des Eintrags

Blättern
Suchen
Hilfe & Kontakt
Informationen
electronic library verwendet EPrints 3.3.12
Gestaltung Webseite und Datenbank: Copyright © Deutsches Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt (DLR). Alle Rechte vorbehalten.