Low velocity collisions of porous planetesimals in the early solar system

Abstract

The ESA Rosetta mission has shown that Comet 67P/Churuymov–Gerasimenko is bi-lobed, has a high average porosity of around 70%, does not have internal cavities on size scales larger than 10 m, the lobes could have individual sets of onion shell-like layering, and the nucleus surface contains 100 m-scale cylindrical pits. It is currently debated whether these properties are consistent with high-velocity collisional evolution or if they necessarily are surviving signatures of low-velocity primordial accretion. We use an Eulerian hydrocode to study collisions between highly porous bodies of different sizes, material parameters and relative velocities with emphasis on 5–100 m/s to characterize the effects of collisions in terms of deformation, compaction, and heating. We find that accretion of 1 km cometesimals by 3 km nuclei at 13.5 m/s flattens and partially buries the cometesimal with ∼1% reduction of the bulk porosity. This structure locally becomes more dense but the global effect of compaction is minor, suggesting that low-velocity accretion does not lead to a ‘bunch of grapes’ structure with large internal cavities but a more homogeneous interior, consistent with Rosetta findings. The mild local compaction associated with accretion is potentially the origin of the observed nucleus layering. In 2D axially symmetric impacts hit- and-stick collisions of similarly-sized nuclei are possible at velocities up to 30 m/s where deformation becomes severe. The bulk porosity is reduced significantly, even at 30–50 m/s relative velocity. To avoid hit-and-run collisions the impact angle must be less than 35 °–45 °from the surface normal at 10 m/s, and even smaller at higher velocities. Impact heating is insignificant. We find that the small cross section of the 67P neck may require a less than 5 m/s impact, unless the cohesion exceeds 10 kPa. We conclude that bi-lobe nucleus formation is possible at velocities typically discussed in hierarchical growth scenarios. Impacts of a 7 m projectile at 10 0–500 m/s create a rimless cylindrical shaft with vertical walls, up to 50 m wide and 70 m deep. These shafts bear some resemblance with the pits on 67P, particularly if the depth-to-width ratio is reduced by nucleus erosion. Collisions between similarly-sized nuclei above 100 m/s lead to complete disintegration, and even small fragments suffer different degrees of compaction. Thus, we strongly doubt that 67P has been subjected to high-velocity collisions by projectiles larger than those that might have formed the pits, or is the fragment of a larger parent body. We suggest that the observed properties of 67P are more consistent with primordial accretion.