How to Measure Speech Recognition Performance in the Air Traffic Control Domain? The Word Error Rate is only half of the truth

Kurzfassung

Applying Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) in the domain of analogue voice communication between air traffic controllers (ATCo) and pilots has more end user requirements than just transforming spoken words into text. It is useless, when word recognition is perfect, as long as the semantic interpretation is wrong. For an ATCo it is of no importance if the words of greeting are correctly recognized. A wrong recognition of a greeting should, however, not disturb the correct recognition of e.g. a “descend” command. Recently, 14 European partners from Air Traffic Management (ATM) domain have agreed on a common set of rules, i.e., an ontology on how to annotate the speech utterance of an ATCo. This paper first extends the ontology to pilot utterances and then compares different ASR implementations on semantic level by introducing command recognition, command recognition error, and command rejection rates. The implementation used in this paper achieves a command recognition rate better than 94% for Prague Approach, even when WER is above 2.5%